My Local Eats: New York

Welcome to My Local Eats, a guest post series in which foodies from around the globe share their favorite local places to eat and drink. Today we will be learning about what to eat in New York, and so far the series has already covered Paris and Seoul.

Today the series makes its foray into North America with Ashley Hufford’s favorite spots in New York, New York. Ashley, apart from having a very cool first name (cough), writes See Ash Run, a blog that chronicles her life and photography in New York.

Ashley Hufford

Hi, I’m Ash, a New York Native/Travel addict who’s currently traveling around the world via New York neighborhoods. I can go from Paris to Italy, from Brazil to Spain, from China to Africa all for the price of a subway ticket. And for the adventurer who can’t afford to adventure right now, this is a decent tradeoff. Ashley Abroad (it was weird when I just wrote Ashley) gave me the opportunity to share with you some of my favorite New York City “Travel” destinations.

 Tea and Sympathy  

Lets start off in jolly old Londonland!

What to Eat in New York

When Nikki Perry came to New York from London, she was determined to find a home for British cuisine and that was what she did by pretty much creating Little Britain with her now staple restaurant, Tea & Sympathy. This tiny restaurant could be easily over looked when walking down Greenwich Ave. But, especially on a weekend morning, you won’t miss the swarms of people waiting for a seat inside this 23 person (max) restaurant. Tea & Sympathy is the quintessential British Tea Shop, with over 25 different tea flavors, scones and (almost) authentic clotted cream, the actual clotted cream is banned in the US for pasteurization laws, but this stuff is fantastic.

What to Eat in New York

Although known mostly for its traditional English Breakfast on Saturday and Sundays, Tea & Sympathy is also filled with delicious sandwiches, tasty dinner pies and melt in your mouth desserts. My recommendations? The Traditional English Breakfast Tea, the Welsh Rarebit, a savory cheese and toast dish that may change your life, and the rhubarb pudding! (Ms. Perry also owns two other British themed stores on the block, A Fish and Chips restaurant called “A Salt and Battery” and “Carry on Tea & Sympathy” a British convenience store which sells British goods and food.)

What to Eat in New York

Welsh Rarebit

One thing to note, this restaurant has very strict rules like there is a required 10-12 dollar minimum per person (depending on the time you go) and they will not seat you until your entire party is there, some people find these overbearing, I think it adds to the charm!

[learn_more caption=”Location:”] Tea and Sympathy 108 Greenwich Avenue Manhattan (212) 807-8329  Metro: Anything that stops on 14th is in walking distance. Open Weekdays 11-10, Weekends 9-10[/learn_more]


Fatty’s Cafe

Now I may be a bit biased because I live there, but Astoria, Queens is one of the most diverse and authentic neighborhoods in New York and is pretty much untouched by tourists. Astoria is known for its Greek food and people, but also has vibrant Moroccan and Eastern European influences as well. My favorite restaurant in Astoria is none of these three things. In fact, we will half to take a little hop over to Cuba.

What to Eat in New York

If you’re looking for tasty Cuban cuisine and probably the best mojito in the city, hike out to Astoria, Queens and take yourself to Fatty’s Cafe. It’s a small, brightly colored restaurant during the day and a fun, musical bar at night, with two of the kindest owners in New York, Sue and Ferd. Anyone who’s a Fatty’s patron knows these two, because they’ll make an effort to know you the second you walk through the door. Besides its atmosphere, the food is delicious, I have eaten almost everything on the menu and there is nothing I don’t like. On weekends they have a fantastic brunch and for only 15 dollars you get a meal and a drink, which is probably the best deal you’ll find in New York. My recommendation is the Chorizo Tacos and their mojito. (I am a huge mojito drinker and this one is the best I’ve ever had.)

Note: In the summer they have the greatest outdoor area, which lights and bamboo coverings. I promise the trek to this restaurant is worth it.

[learn_more caption=”Location:”] Fatty’s Cafe 2501 Ditmars Boulevard Astoria (718) 267-7071 Nearest Transit Station: Astoria – Ditmars Blvd (N, Q) Hours: Mon-Thu 2 pm – 11 pm Fri 2 pm – 12 am Sat 11 am – 12 am Sun 11 am – 10 pm[/learn_more]


The Tuck Shop

Our last stop on our adventure is down under.

What to Eat in New York

When Americans go to a baseball game, we eat hotdogs. When Aussies go to a football match, they eat meat pies! At least according to “The Tuck Shop,” the Australian Meat pie restaurant, located in 3 different locations around Manhattan. It’s open late so its the perfect spot for an after-drink bite. The menu is incredible simple, cheap and full of yummy pies. Don’t worry veggies, they have food for you too!

What to Eat in New York

What to Eat in New York

Whenever I go I meet awesome travelers and hear hysterical stories, plus they have a book exchange where you can trade in your old guide books and get another. Oh did I mention they also home make all of their own sodas which is pretty awesome and quick tasty. My recommendation is the BBQ Pork Pie with the Cole Slaw and an Elderberry soda!

[learn_more caption=”Location:”] The Tuck Shop: A Great Aussie Bite For any information you need on any of the locations check out their website. [/learn_more]

[author] [author_image timthumb=’on’][/author_image] [author_info]Ashley Hufford is a blogger and video editor living in New York City. She spends her days writing, playing the ukulele, drinking tea, babysitting and freelancing, but not always in that order. To hear more about her post-grad, caffeine-fueled, New York City adventures follow her on Twitter @AshleyHufford.[/author_info] [/author]

What are your favorite things to eat in New York?

Enjoyed this post? Subscribe here!

Subscribe here to receive new Ashley Abroad posts straight to your inbox.

I'll never send you spam. And you can unsubscribe at any time. Powered by ConvertKit
This post may have affiliate links, which means I may receive commissions if you choose to purchase through links I provide (at no extra cost to you). Please read my disclosure for more info.
About Ashley Fleckenstein

Ashley is a travel and lifestyle blogger who lives in Ann Arbor, Michigan. Since college she has au paired in Paris, backpacked the world solo, and lived in Uganda. Her work has been featured by Buzzfeed, Forbes, TripAdvisor, and Glamour Magazine.

6 thoughts on “My Local Eats: New York”

  1. Oh I love the idea of traveling around the (food) world with a subway ticket! I want to try all these restaurants right now – and I just can’t wait to visit New York City someday!

  2. This made me sooo miss home! I LOVE that NYC’s diversity is so well-reflected in its food. My weakness was always the hole-in-the-wall ramen shop. And the last photo made me laugh. “No shit books please!” Yeah, that’s New York.

  3. Oooh, I loved Fatty’s! Also, Tea & Sympathy and The Tuck Shop look amazing. We’re definitely going there next time I visit! I’ve only had one meat pie in my life but it was a good experience!

Comments are closed.